RE: Should the meaning of properties change dependent on structure? (was CC/PP components)

Hi Mark,

> From: ext Butler, Mark [mailto:Mark_Butler@hplb.hpl.hp.com]
...

> 1. Is it better to have properties change their meaning 
> dependent on where
> they are in a profile structure 
...

> Art Barstow has suggested that if CC/PP should allow approach 
> 1 and if it
> does not then it is broken.

This is a gross mis-representation of what I said:

> > If CC/PP does not permit an Attribute (e.g. ExpirationDate) to
> > be in different Components (i.e. CreditCard and Session) then
> > it seems to me that CC/PP is broken.  (RDF itself certainly does not
> > care.)

Regards,

Art Barstow
---