W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > www-international@w3.org > October to December 2004

Re: Language Identifier List Criteria

From: Tex Texin <tex@xencraft.com>
Date: Mon, 20 Dec 2004 13:26:43 -0800
Message-ID: <41C74393.4B78AEB@xencraft.com>
To: Georg Schweizer <gschweizer@gmx.at>
CC: www-international@w3.org, ietf-languages@alvestrand.no

Well, I will leave it to others to debate the characterization of the standards
as political, if they choose to.
However, RFC 3066's approach is generative. So de-AT is created by combining
codes from each of ISO 639 and ISO 3166, and neither defines what this means.
In fact RFC 3066 only defines the production and not which of the produced
values are meaningful or what they mean except in the most general terms.
That's why we are having this discussion.

Under RFC 3066 it is possible to create combinations of language and region
that have no useful value.
So this need not be determined politically.

For myself, I am looking for guidance for software and web producers. Which
labels to use when tagging content? When is there a enough of a difference that
bears paying for a translation?

It is not clear to me it should be purely linguistic however.
Politics is perhaps one element of the criteria.
tex


Georg Schweizer wrote:
> 
> > Some languages are spoken in many countries, and the language is not
> > distinctive in each country. I have started to accept suggestions as
> > to which language-region codes do not represent a distinct language
> > variation, and therefore are not recommended as tags, without good
> > reason.
> http://www.i18nguy.com/unicode/language-identifiers.html
> 
> The criteria should be political rather than linguistic ones, as both
> the ISO 639 language tags and the ISO 3166 country codes are based on
> political agreement. Therefore I would not speak of "distict language
> variations", but of distinct *official standards* (or at least distinct
> conventions). Variations can be found everywhere (even within one
> political region), whereas the same conventions can be followed by
> several countries.

-- 
-------------------------------------------------------------
Tex Texin   cell: +1 781 789 1898   mailto:Tex@XenCraft.com
Xen Master                          http://www.i18nGuy.com
                         
XenCraft		            http://www.XenCraft.com
Making e-Business Work Around the World
-------------------------------------------------------------
Received on Monday, 20 December 2004 21:26:53 GMT

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.2.0+W3C-0.50 : Tuesday, 2 June 2009 19:17:04 GMT