Re: Extraneous Characters in Netscape Display

Alexander, Larry (lalexander@acad.com)
Thu, 25 May 95 08:31:44 PST


Date: Thu, 25 May 95 08:31:44 PST
From: "Alexander, Larry" <lalexander@acad.com>
Message-Id: <9504258014.AA801416093@clink.acad.com>
To: www-html@www10.w3.org
Subject: Re: Extraneous Characters in Netscape Display

>> I have been creating Web pages using the Netscape rules file in HoTMetaL 
>> Pro. Problems appear when I have pages with special entities. Each file 
>> begins with:
>>
>> <!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//Netscape Corp.//DTD HTML plus Tables//EN" >> 
"html-net.dtd"
>> [
>> <!ENTITY pound CDATA "">
>> ]>
>>
>> When using NCSA Mosaic v2B4 everything looks fine. However, with Spry 
Air >> or Netscape, I see:
>>
>> ]>
>>
>> at the head of each page.
>>
>> Is HoTMetaL doing something illegal with the !ENTITY declaration?

Paul Grosso wrote:
>The document type declaration--including the optional 'internal subset' 
>(the part from [ to ] inclusive)--is valid SGML.

[snip]

>I also note, however, that the Public Identifier you show is not one 
>of the valid choices given in the HTML 2.0 spec.

And then Walter wrote:

>I think what HoTMetaL Pro *should* do is place the extra stuff in a 
>comment, and leave the doctype as standard HTML. SoftQuad, can you hear 
>me? :)

I couldn't agree more with Walter's assessment. If I remove the Netscape 
from the doctype, then I no longer have access in HoTMetaL Pro to the 
Netscape specific tags such as <CENTER>, etc. Since the browsers generally 
seem to ignore the doctype anyway, I could probably create my pages with 
the Netscape doctype so HoTMetaL uses the correct rules file, and then 
manually change the doctype to the standard default. Of course, I won't do 
this... but it is tempting... ;-) SoftQuad, are you listening?

Larry