W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > www-forms-editor@w3.org > November 2009

XForms in HTML Example will not validate

From: Robert C. Leif <rleif@rleif.com>
Date: Tue, 17 Nov 2009 06:45:30 +0100
To: www-forms-editor@w3.org
Message-ID: <048a01ca6749$10666520$31332f60$@com>
Dear Editor,

I tried to make The example in Section H  
(http://www.w3.org/TR/2009/REC-xforms-20091020/#xforms-in-xhtml-00) and  
the downloadable example (attached) work with both XMLSpy and OxYgen.  
OxYgen employs a special declaration for XForms that includes Relax NG  
code. <?oxygen NVDLSchema="xhtml-xforms.nvdl"?>. This does not appear to  
be portable. In short,  I would like to be able to use my CytometryML  
schemas with XForms including being able to have type checking active.  
Since the CytometryML schemas are proposed to be part of a standard, these  
schemas will be available without charge.  I believe that the  link to the  
XForms 1.1, W3C Recommendation 20 October 2009 should provide a complete  
working example. I have attached the XForm and schema that I copied from  
the Recommendation. I also tested the XForm with the <?xml version="1.0"  
encoding="UTF-8"?> declaration removed. It produced similar errors.  Since  
html does not include XForms, the errors appear to be correct.  I have  
tested some approaches that appear to interfere with html’s schema  
validating elements from other namespaces. However, they did not work  
either.



Thank you.

Robert C. Leif, Ph.D.

Vice President

Newport Instruments

5648 Toyon Road

San Diego, CA 92115

Tel. (619)582-0437

Email rleif@rleif.com

Web : www.newportinstruments.com

“ Complete XForms Examples (Non-Normative)

This section presents complete XForms examples. These and additional  
examples are maintained at http://www.w3.org/MarkUp/Forms/2002/Examples.

H.1 XForms in XHTML.”



I

XMLSpy error message:

File F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test.html is not valid.

                 Element 'html' has no declaration for an attribute named  
'xmlns:xf'.

                                 Error location: html / @xmlns:xf

                                 Details

                                                 VC: Attribute Value Type:  
Element 'html' has no declaration for an attribute named 'xmlns:xf'.



OYgen 11 Editor error messages:

SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Attribute "xmlns:my" must be declared for element type "html".

Start location: 2:7

End location: 2:53



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Attribute "xmlns:ev" must be declared for element type "html".

Start location: 2:54

End location: 2:98



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Attribute "xmlns:xsd" must be declared for element type  
"html".

Start location: 3:3

End location: 3:47



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Attribute "xmlns:xforms" must be declared for element type  
"html".

Start location: 3:48

End location: 3:92



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:model" must be declared.

Start location: 8:6

End location: 8:18



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:instance" must be declared.

Start location: 9:8

End location: 9:23



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "my:payment" must be declared.

Start location: 10:10

End location: 10:20



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "my:cc" must be declared.

Start location: 11:12

End location: 11:17



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:submission" must be declared.

Start location: 15:8

End location: 15:25



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:bind" must be declared.

Start location: 16:8

End location: 16:19



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:bind" must be declared.

Start location: 17:8

End location: 17:19



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Unexpected element "xforms:model". The content of the parent  
element type must match  
"((script|style|meta|link|object)*,((title,(script|style|meta|link|object)*,(base,(script|style|meta|link|object)*)?)|(base,(script|style|meta|link|object)*,(title,(script|style|meta|link|object)*))))".

Start location: 8:6

End location: 8:18



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:group" must be declared.

Start location: 21:6

End location: 21:18



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:trigger" must be declared.

Start location: 22:8

End location: 22:22



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:label" must be declared.

Start location: 24:10

End location: 24:22



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "toggle" must be declared.

Start location: 25:10

End location: 25:16



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:trigger" must be declared.

Start location: 27:8

End location: 27:22



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:label" must be declared.

Start location: 28:10

End location: 28:22



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "toggle" must be declared.

Start location: 29:10

End location: 29:16



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Unexpected element "xforms:group". The content of the parent  
element type must match  
"(p|h1|h2|h3|h4|h5|h6|div|ul|ol|dl|pre|hr|blockquote|address|fieldset|table|form|noscript|ins|del|script)*".

Start location: 21:6

End location: 21:18



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "switch" must be declared.

Start location: 34:6

End location: 34:12



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "case" must be declared.

Start location: 35:8

End location: 35:12



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "select1" must be declared.

Start location: 36:10

End location: 36:17



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:label" must be declared.

Start location: 37:12

End location: 37:24



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "choices" must be declared.

Start location: 38:12

End location: 38:19



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "item" must be declared.

Start location: 39:14

End location: 39:18



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:label" must be declared.

Start location: 40:16

End location: 40:28



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "value" must be declared.

Start location: 41:16

End location: 41:21



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "message" must be declared.

Start location: 43:16

End location: 43:23



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "item" must be declared.

Start location: 46:14

End location: 46:18



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:label" must be declared.

Start location: 47:16

End location: 47:28



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "value" must be declared.

Start location: 48:16

End location: 48:21



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:input" must be declared.

Start location: 54:10

End location: 54:22



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:label" must be declared.

Start location: 55:12

End location: 55:24



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "alert" must be declared.

Start location: 56:12

End location: 56:17



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:input" must be declared.

Start location: 60:10

End location: 60:22



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:label" must be declared.

Start location: 62:12

End location: 62:24



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "submit" must be declared.

Start location: 65:10

End location: 65:16



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:label" must be declared.

Start location: 66:12

End location: 66:24



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "case" must be declared.

Start location: 69:8

End location: 69:12



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "select1" must be declared.

Start location: 71:10

End location: 71:17



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:label" must be declared.

Start location: 72:12

End location: 72:24



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "choices" must be declared.

Start location: 73:12

End location: 73:19



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "item" must be declared.

Start location: 74:14

End location: 74:18



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:label" must be declared.

Start location: 75:16

End location: 75:28



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "value" must be declared.

Start location: 76:16

End location: 76:21



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "message" must be declared.

Start location: 77:16

End location: 77:23



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "item" must be declared.

Start location: 80:14

End location: 80:18



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:label" must be declared.

Start location: 81:16

End location: 81:28



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "value" must be declared.

Start location: 82:16

End location: 82:21



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:input" must be declared.

Start location: 88:10

End location: 88:22



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:label" must be declared.

Start location: 89:12

End location: 89:24



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "alert" must be declared.

Start location: 90:12

End location: 90:17



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:input" must be declared.

Start location: 94:10

End location: 94:22



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:label" must be declared.

Start location: 95:12

End location: 95:24



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "submit" must be declared.

Start location: 99:10

End location: 99:16



SystemID: F:\XForms\XForms_XHTML\xforms_test_xf.html

Engine name: Xerces

Severity: error

Description: Element type "xforms:label" must be declared.

Start location: 100:12

End location: 100:24



Received on Tuesday, 17 November 2009 11:01:53 GMT

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.2.0+W3C-0.50 : Tuesday, 17 November 2009 11:01:54 GMT