W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > w3c-sgml-wg@w3.org > August 1997

XML Namespaces: Results of Montreal Meeting 22-Aug-97

From: Andrew Layman <andrewl@microsoft.com>
Date: Sun, 24 Aug 1997 12:20:58 -0700
Message-ID: <7BB61B44F197D011892800805FD4F79201436011@RED-03-MSG.dns.microsoft.com>
To: w3c-sgml-wg@w3.org
Cc: "Dan Connolly [connolly@w3.org] (E-mail)" <connolly@w3.org>
Several important design decisions regarding XML namespaces were
concluded at the XML meeting in Montreal this past Friday. The attached
document contains my understanding of the resulting definition of XML
namespaces and their application to document instances. It is
essentially the same as the "Layman-Bray" namespace proposal, but has
been refined in a number of particulars, so I recommend a careful
reading of the document.

Dan: Can you post this, superceding the similar document I sent a week
ago?

 

--Andrew Layman, Microsoft Corporation

begin 600 layman-namespace.html
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M3"!.86UE<W!A8V5S/"]H,3X-"@T*/'`^1&5S:6=N(&1E8VES:6]N<R!R96%C
M:&5D(&%T('1H92!834P@5T<@;65E=&EN9R!I;B!-;VYT<F5A;"P@0V%N861A
M+"!!=6=U<W0@,C(L(#$Y.#<N/"]P/@T*#0H\<#Y%9&ET;W(Z(#QA9&1R97-S
M/D%N9')E=R!,87EM86XL($UI8W)O<V]F="!#;W)P;W)A=&EO;BP@86YD<F5W
M;$!M:6-R;W-O9G0N8V]M/"]A9&1R97-S/CPO<#X-"@T*/'`^0W5R<F5N=&QY
M+"!834P@9&]C=6UE;G1S('5S92!N86UE<R`H92YG+B!E;&5M96YT(&YA;65S
M+`T*871T<FEB=71E(&YA;65S+"!E=&,N*2!W:&]S92!M96%N:6YG(&ES(&%S
M<V]C:6%T960@=VET:"!T:&4-"F1O8W5M96YT)W,@/&5M/F1O8W5M96YT('1Y
M<&4\+V5M/BX@5&AE($1O8W5M96YT(%1Y<&4@1&5F:6YI=&EO;B`H1%1$*0T*
M<V5R=F5S(&)O=&@@=&\@9&5F:6YE#0IA(&-L87-S(&]F(&1O8W5M96YT(&%N
M9"!A;'-O(&$@/&5M/FYA;65S<&%C93PO96T^("AA;&P@=&AE(&YA;65S('1H
M870@8V%N#0IB92!U<V5D('=I=&AI;B!T:&4@9&]C=6UE;G0@='EP92DN(%1H
M97)E(&%R92!N;R!S:6UP;&4L#0IS=&%N9&%R9&EZ960@;65A;G,@=&\@97AP
M<F5S<R!A(&1O8W5M96YT('1Y<&4@=VAI8V@@=7-E<R!N86UE<PT*9G)O;2!S
M979E<F%L(&YA;65S<&%C97,N(%1H:7,@<&%P97(@<')O<&]S97,@82!C;VYC
M97!T=6%L(&UO9&5L(&%N9`T*8V]N8W)E=&4@<WEN=&%X(&9O<B!A;B!I;7!L
M96UE;G1A=&EO;B!O9B!N86UE<W!A8V5S+@T*1&]C=6UE;G0@:6YS=&%N8V5S
M(&UA>2!U<V4@;F%M97,@9G)O;2!S979E<F%L('-P86-E<RP@=VAI;&4@8F5I
M;F<-"G-E;&8M9&5S8W)I8FEN9R!R96=A<F1I;F<@=&AE(&YA;65S<&%C97,@
M=&AE>2!E;7!L;WD@*'1H870@:7,L#0IR96-O9VYI=&EO;B!O9B!A(&YA;65S
M<&%C92!I<R!N;W0@9&5P96YD96YT(&]N(&AA=FEN9R!R96%D('1H92`-"G)E
M<V]U<F-E('=H:6-H(&1E9FEN97,@:70I+CPO<#X-"@T*/'`^0G)I969L>2P@
M82!N86UE<W!A8V4@:&%S(&$-"F1E9FEN:6YG('-C:&5M82P@<W5C:"!A<R!A
M($141"X@5&AE('-C:&5M82!D969I;F5S(&$@;G5M8F5R#0IO9B!N86UE<R`H
M92YG+B!E;&5M96YT<RP@871T<FEB=71E<RP@;F]T871I;VYS+"!E=&,N*2X@
M5&AE#0IS8VAE;6$@8V%N(&)E(')E86-H960@=FEA(&$@55)).R!T:&ES(%52
M22!I<R!T:&4@:61E;G1I9FEE<B!O9@T*=&AE(&YA;65S<&%C92X@06QL('!A
M<G1I8W5L87(@;F%M97,@87)E(#QE;3YQ=6%L:69I960\+V5M/BP@=&AA=`T*
M:7,L('1H97D@8V]N<VES="!O9B!T=V\@<&%R=',Z('1H92!N86UE<W!A8V4G
M<R!I9&5N=&EF:65R(&%N9"!T:&4-"G-P96-I9FEC(&YA;64@=VET:&EN('1H
M92!N86UE<W!A8V4@*&4N9RX@=&AE(%5222!T;R!T:&4@<V-H96UA(&%N9`T*
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M;GD@<F5A9&5R(&]F(&$@9&]C=6UE;G0@=&\@9FEN9`T*=&AE(&=L;V)A;&QY
M+75N:7%U92P@9G5L;'DM<75A;&EF:65D(&9O<FT@;V8@96%C:"!N86UE+B!)
M="!H87,@;F\-"G-P96-I86P@<')O=FES:6]N<R!F;W(@87-S;V-I871I;F<@
M<V5M86YT:6-S('=I=&@@;F%M97,N($$-"FYA;65S<&%C92`\96T^<&5R('-E
M/"]E;3X@9&]E<R!N;W0@:6UP;'D@86YY('-P96-I9FEC(&UE86YI;F<@=&\-
M"G1H92!N86UE<R!D969I;F5D(&EN(&ET+B!)="!H87,@;F]T:&EN9R!S<&5C
M:6%L('1O(&1O('=I=&@@=F%L:61A=&EO;BP@#0IM=6QT:7!L92!I;FAE<FET
M86YC92P@9F]R;6%T=&EN9RP@=F5R<VEO;FEN9RP@8G)E=FET>2P@;W(-"F%N
M>71H:6YG(&)E<VED97,@;6%K:6YG('-U<F4@=&AA="!N86UE<R!A<F4@9VQO
M8F%L;'DM=6YI<75E(&%N9`T*9VQO8F%L;'DM9&5F:6YE9"X\+W`^#0H-"CQH
M,CY);B!T:&4@26YS=&%N8V4\+V@R/@T*#0H\<#Y792!R97-E<G9E(&%N9"!P
M<F4M9&5F:6YE('1H90T*<W!E8VEA;"!P<F]C97-S:6YG(&EN<W1R=6-T:6]N
M(&-A;&QE9"`F<75O=#MX;6PZ;F%M97-P86-E)G%U;W0[#0IW:&EC:"!W:6QL
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M97,@/&5M/FYS/"]E;3X@=VET:"`\96T^=7)I/"]E;3XL#0IS=6-H('1H870@
M/&5M/FYS/"]E;3X@8V%N(&)E('5S960@87,@82!S=&%N9"UI;B!F;W(@/&5M
M/G5R:3PO96T^#0IA<R!T:&4@;F%M97-P86-E)W,@:61E;G1I9FEE<B`H=&AE
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M('!A<G1S+"`\96T^=7)I/"]E;3X-"F%N9"`\96T^<W!E8VEF:6,M;F%M93PO
M96T^+B!&;W(@97AA;7!L93H\+W`^#0H-"CQP/E1H:7,@:6YT<F]D=6-E<R!T
M:&4@;F%M97-P86-E(&EN=&\@=&AE('-C;W!E(&]F#0II=',@8V]N=&%I;FEN
M9R!D;V-U;65N="P@<W5C:"!T:&%T(#QE;3YN<SPO96T^(&-A;B!B92!U<V5D
M(&%S('1O#0IQ=6%L:69Y(&%N>2!E;&5M96YT(&EN('1H92!D;V-U;65N="X\
M+W`^#0H-"CQP<F4^)FQT.S]X;6PZ;F%M97-P86-E(&AR968])G%U;W0[:'1T
M<#HO+WIO;RYO<F<O<V-H96UA+F1T9"\F<75O=#L@87,])G%U;W0[>F]O)G%U
M;W0[/R9G=#L-"B9L=#MZ;V\Z86YI;6%L1G)I96YD<R9G=#L-"B`@)FQT.WIO
M;SI"96%R)F=T.T-H<FES=&]P:&5R)FQT.R]Z;V\Z0F5A<B9G=#L-"B`@)FQT
M.WIO;SI286)B:70F9W0[4V%B<FEN829L=#LO>F]O.E)A8F)I="9G=#L-"B9L
M=#LO>F]O.F%N:6UA;$9R:65N9',F9W0[/"]P<F4^#0H-"CQP/BA792!W:6QL
M(&1I<V-U<W,@;&%T97(@82!M96-H86YI<VT@=&AA="!G<F5A=&QY(')E9'5C
M97,@=&AE(&YE960@=&\@<75A;&EF>2`-"F5V97)Y(&YA;64@97AP;&EC:71L
M>2XI/"]P/@T*#0H\<#Y.86UE<W!A8V5S(&YO="!O;FQY('-E<G9E('1O('1I
M92!A(&YA;64@=&\@82!P87)T:6-U;&%R(&1E9FEN:71I;VXL('1H97D-"F%L
M<V\@9&ES86UB:6=U871E('-I;6EL87(M<V5E;6EN9R!N86UE<R!W:71H:6X@
M82!S:6YG;&4@9&]C=6UE;G0N/"]P/@T*#0H\<')E/B9L=#L_>&UL.FYA;65S
M<&%C92!H<F5F/29Q=6]T.VAT='`Z+R]Z;V\N;W)G+W-C:&5M82YD=&0O)G%U
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M=#MS;VUE16QE;65N="9G=#L-"B`@)FQT.WIO;SI"96%R)F=T.T-H<FES=&]P
M:&5R)FQT.R]Z;V\Z0F5A<B9G=#L-"B`@)FQT.VUA<FME=#I"96%R)F=T.V1O
M=VX@,3(W('!O:6YT<R9L=#LO;6%R:V5T.D)E87(F9W0[#0H@("9L=#MN878Z
M0F5A<B9G=#M.;W)T:"!B>2!.;W)T:'=E<W0F;'0[+VYA=CI"96%R)F=T.PT*
M)FQT.R]S;VUE16QE;65N="9G=#L\+W!R93X-"@T*/&@R/E5N<75A;&EF:65D
M($YA;65S/"]H,CX-"@T*/'`^06QL(&YA;65S(&EN(&$@9&]C=6UE;G0@:&%V
M92!A#0IF=6QL>2UQ=6%L:69I960@9F]R;2X@56YL97-S(&5X<&QI8VET;'D@
M<75A;&EF:65D+"!T:&4@;W5T97)M;W-T(&5L96UE;G0@:6X@82!D;V-U;65N
M="!I<PT*86QW87ES(&%S<W5M960@=&\@8V]M92!F<F]M('1H92!D;V-U;65N
M="=S($141"!N86UE<W!A8V4N#0I&;W(@8V]N=&%I;F5D(&5L96UE;G1S+`T*
M=&AE(&5X<&QI8VET(&YA;65S<&%C92!A;F0@)G%U;W0[.B9Q=6]T.R!C86X@
M86QS;R!B92!O;6ET=&5D+B!)9@T*<V\L('1H92!E;F-L;W-I;F<@96QE;65N
M="=S(&YA;65S<&%C92!I<R!I;F9E<G)E9"`H9F]R#0IS=6(M96QE;65N=',L
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M:&5R)FQT.R]"96%R)F=T.PT*("`F;'0[4F%B8FET('-I>F4])G%U;W0[<VUA
M;&PF<75O=#L@9F]O9#IE871S/29Q=6]T.V1A;F1I;&EO;G,F<75O=#LF9W0[
M4V%B<FEN829L=#LO4F%B8FET)F=T.PT*)FQT.R]Z;V\Z86YI;6%L1G)I96YD
M<R9G=#L\+W!R93X-"@T*/'`^2&5R92P@/&5M/D)E87(\+V5M/BP@/&5M/E)A
M8F)I=#PO96T^+"!A;F0@/&5M/G-I>F4\+V5M/@T*87)E('%U86QI9FEE9"!T
M;R!T:&4@/&5M/FAT='`Z+R]Z;V\N;W)G+W-C:&5M82YD=&0O/"]E;3X@;F%M
M97-P86-E+`T*=VAI;&4@/&5M/F5A=',\+V5M/B!I<R!Q=6%L:69I960@=&\-
M"CQE;3YH='1P.B\O9F]O9'-T;W)E+F-O;2]S8VAE;6$N9'1D+SPO96T^+CPO
M<#X-"@T*/'`^5&AE('!R92UD969I;F5D(&%T=')I8G5T92`\96T^>&UL.F-H
M:6QD+6YA;65S<&%C93PO96T^('-E=',@82!D969A=6QT(&YA;65S<&%C92!F
M;W(-"F-O;G1A:6YE9"!E;&5M96YT<R!D:69F97)I;F<@9G)O;2!T:&%T(&]F
M('1H92!P87)E;G0N/"]P/@T*#0H\<')E/B9L=#L_>&UL.FYA;65S<&%C92!H
M<F5F/29Q=6]T.VAT='`Z+R]Z;V\N;W)G+W-C:&5M82YD=&0O)G%U;W0[(&%S
M/29Q=6]T.WIO;R9Q=6]T.S\F9W0[#0HF;'0[/WAM;#IN86UE<W!A8V4@:')E
M9CTF<75O=#MH='1P.B\O=S,N;W)G+TA434PO<V-H96UA+F1T9"\F<75O=#L@
M87,])G%U;W0[:'1M;"9Q=6]T.S\F9W0[#0HF;'0[:'1M;#IU;"!X;6PZ8VAI
M;&0M;F%M97-P86-E/2)Z;V\B)F=T.PT*("`F;'0[0F5A<B9G=#M#:')I<W1O
M<&AE<B9L=#LO0F5A<B9G=#L-"B`@)FQT.U)A8F)I="9G=#M386)R:6YA)FQT
M.R]286)B:70F9W0[#0H@("9L=#M0:6<F9W0[0VQA=61E)FQT.R]0:6<F9W0[
M#0H@("9L=#M(961G96AO9R9G=#M!;&9R960F;'0[+TAE9&=E:&]G)F=T.PT*
M)FQT.R]H=&UL.G5L)F=T.SPO<')E/@T*#0H\:#(^4F5F97)E;F-E<SPO:#(^
M#0H-"CQU;#X-"B`@("`\;&D^/&5M/D]P=&EO;G,@9F]R($EM<&QE;65N=&EN
M9R!.86UE<W!A8V5S(&EN(%A-3#PO96T^(`T*("`@("`@("`H/&$@:')E9CTB
M:'1T<#HO+W=W=RYW,RYO<F<O6$U,+T=R;W5P+SDW,#4O;F%M97-P86-E+FAT
M;2(^:'1T<#HO+W=W=RYW,RYO<F<O6$U,+T=R;W5P+SDW,#4O;F%M97-P86-E
M+FAT;3PO83XI/"]L:3X-"B`@("`\;&D^/&5M/E)E<V]U<F-E($1E<V-R:7!T
M:6]N#0H@("`@("`@($9R86UE=V]R:R`H4D1&*2!-;V1E;"!A;F0@4WEN=&%X
M/"]E;3X@#0H@("`@("`@("@\82!H<F5F/2)H='1P.B\O=W=W+G<S+F]R9R]-
M96UB97(O.3<P."]71"UR9&8M<WEN=&%X+3DW,#@P,2YH=&UL(CYH='1P.B\O
M=W=W+G<S+F]R9R]-96UB97(O.3<P."]71"UR9&8M<WEN=&%X+3DW,#@P,2YH
G=&UL/"]A/CPO;&D^#0H\+W5L/@T*#0H\+V)O9'D^#0H\+VAT;6P^
`
end
Received on Sunday, 24 August 1997 15:21:03 UTC

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.3.1 : Tuesday, 6 January 2015 21:25:27 UTC