W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > whatwg@whatwg.org > October 2014

[whatwg] URL: test case review

From: Sam Ruby <rubys@intertwingly.net>
Date: Sun, 05 Oct 2014 21:13:43 -0400
Message-ID: <5431ECC7.2050009@intertwingly.net>
To: whatwg@whatwg.org
I've been reviewing urltestdata[1], and I've identified a number of 
results that seem problematic, questionable, marginal, or otherwise 
worth further discussion.

More specifically, I've been comparing the "expected" results against 
what a number of browsers produce.  I've not gone back and cross-checked 
against the specification, so in the event that any if the results I've 
flagged are a problem, the problem could lie in a number of places: the 
spec, the testcase, in my tooling, or in my evaluation.

----

Problematic:

http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/24f081633d
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/3ce4f5de09
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/4b60e32190
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/d674c14cbe
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/4b60e32190
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/ddd9247435
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/d674c14cbe
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/e12c69e98f
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/424e74c451
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/61a4a14209
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/bc6ea8bdf8

Questionable:

http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/0186819198
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/79e1a94e3f
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/ac8eac1a5f
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/06a53cdbdb
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/a356f7d1d2
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/1ee3b66e78
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/ff7f133cf3
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/249400c47e
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/7a0e86d240
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/1c7e19a680
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/2ec861ea91
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/b5b44746b8
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/81e4adf18a
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/102e7f27ee
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/4e7c0a2848
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/f3382f1412
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/f9334f0f29
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/683ac9869d

Marginable:

http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/4038fcfa6d
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/4c127b3460
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/1bdb1f0518
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/153d5e2db3
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/cd5c072d40
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/6735fb18b3
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/9ff20552e2
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/dee8f05a53
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/66ecd94b26
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/9c180b2434
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/b0a8bbbd91
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/a34dae7ab1
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/15676a7e5b
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/e170ad9cce
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/6ae2e1fba4
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/f5aa84f2b7
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/5ca805894a
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/e69449a120
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/94fdad613f
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/fb5f4ecb7f
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/bb6d4fe736
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/452df01d16
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/c0f5f62539
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/879d9d39f2
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/170a75ed1a
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/193a21faf8
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/427f21ba05
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/3e3e806c7a
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/dd853363e9
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/3acff6043c
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/aa0a198c57
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/3e384d800f
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/69a2685fb3
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/1048ef38db
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/ee52a7413c
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/723aa80622

Worth Discussing:

http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/e0d78e8c36
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/eb30a2c2d0
http://intertwingly.net/stories/2014/10/05/urltest-results/e170ad9cce

---

Further background on my methodology and results:

http://intertwingly.net/blog/2014/10/02/WHATWG-URL-vs-IETF-URI

- Sam Ruby

[1] 
https://raw.githubusercontent.com/w3c/web-platform-tests/master/url/urltestdata.txt
Received on Monday, 6 October 2014 01:14:09 UTC

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.3.1 : Monday, 13 April 2015 23:09:31 UTC