W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > whatwg@whatwg.org > June 2006

[whatwg] Mathematics in HTML5

From: Michel Fortin <michel.fortin@michelf.com>
Date: Wed, 7 Jun 2006 19:50:17 -0400
Message-ID: <0969AA59-05C5-436A-A2B6-E538DBAA1811@michelf.com>
Le 7 juin 2006 ? 14:47, Ian Hickson a ?crit :

> So, while I applaud the re-use of ISO12083 here, it seems like an odd
> choice. The resulting language seems to be just as verbose as  
> MathML, so
> why not just reuse MathML, which already has a Web presence? Also,  
> your
> version of the vocabulary doesn't seem quite the same as ISO12083,  
> which
> means we would be introducing yet another mathematical markup  
> language, in
> a space which already has many such languages.

I'd like to try something a little simpler. So here is my idea for a  
math markup.

I wrote that as a cheat sheet, not as a specification, because it was  
simpler for me and because I think it gives a good glimpse at what  
I'm trying to do. But surely a more formal specification with that  
later on. Here it is:

  - - -

Use <var> for variables of any kind, with a "type" attribute to  
identify vector, matrix or other special kinds of variables.

      <var type="vector">x</var>

Use <sup> for exponents.

      <var>x</var><sup>2</sup>

Use <sub> for matrix indices.

      <var type="matrix">X</var><sub>2,2</sub>

Use <frac> for fractions, with <num> and <den> inside, as proposed by  
White and others.

     <frac>
       <num>1</num>
       <den>2</den>
     </frac>

Use <radical> for radicals, with <radix> and <radicand>, as proposed  
by White.

     <radical>
       <radix>2</radix>
       <radicand>2</radicand>
     </radical>

Use <matrix type="..."> for matrices, with <mr> for rows, and <md>  
for cells (like for tables). Just a one column- or a one row- matrix  
for vectors.

     <matrix type="det">
       <mr><md>1</md><md>2</md></mr>
       <mr><md>3</md><md>4</md></mr>
     </matrix>

Use <fence type="..."> for any kind of fence.

     <fence type="floor">expression</fence>

Use <bounds>, <sup>, and <sub> to add lower and upper bounds to  
<fence type="bounds">:

     <fence type="bounds">
       <var>x</var>
       <bounds>
         <sub>0</sub>
         <sup>100<sup>
       </bounds>
     </fence>

Use <integral> and <bounds> for integrals.

     <integral>
       <bounds>
         <sub>0</sub>
         <sup>100<sup>
       </bounds>
       3<var>x</var> d<var>x</var>
     </integral>

Use <sum> and <bounds> for big sum operators.

     <sum>
       <bounds>
         <sub><var>x</var> = 0</sub>
         <sup>100<sup>
       </bounds>
       3<var>x</var>
     </sum>

Use <product> and <bounds> for big product operators.

     <product>
       <bounds>
         <sub><var>x</var> = 0</sub>
         <sup>100<sup>
       </bounds>
       3<var>x</var>
     </product>

Use <limit> for limits:

     <limit>
       <var>x</var> -> 0
     </limit>
     <frac>
       <num><var>x</var></den>
       <den>0</den>
     </frac>

Use <formula> to delimit formulas that should stand out of the main  
prose.

Use ruby annotations for the purpose of over- and under- script/braces.
<http://www.w3.org/TR/ruby/>

Assuming some generic element is adopted for localized numbers, it  
could be reused inside formulas too.

  - - -

Summary

16 new math-specific elements:

*  <frac>, <num>, and <den>
*  <radical>, <radix>, and <radicand>
*  <matrix>, <mr>, and <md>
*  <fence>
*  <bounds>
*  <integral>, <sum>, <product>
*  <limit>
*  <formula>

5 ruby annotation elements:

*  <ruby>
*  <rbc>, <rtc>
*  <rb>, <rt>, <rp>

3 reused HTML elements:

*  <var>
*  <sup>, <sub>

I think all of these new elements can be styled decently with CSS. I  
can't say much myself about how suitable it is for a conversion from  
LaTeX however. I'd appreciate comments on that and any other issue or  
omission.


Michel Fortin
michel.fortin at michelf.com
http://www.michelf.com/
Received on Wednesday, 7 June 2006 16:50:17 UTC

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.3.1 : Monday, 13 April 2015 23:08:27 UTC