W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > whatwg@whatwg.org > January 2005

[whatwg] WebForms vs XForms

From: Håkon Wium Lie <howcome@opera.com>
Date: Fri, 7 Jan 2005 07:45:51 +0100
Message-ID: <16862.12319.47447.195405@howcome.oslo.opera.com>
Also sprach Jon Ferraiolo:

 > I haven't been following WebForms in the past few months, but when my 
 > colleague Bill McCoy told me that he has participated in this forum, I took 
 > a look.

Great to have you here!

 > I looked at the WebForms 2.0 spec and was surprised at its size. I created 
 > a PDF out of the WebForms spec and got 101 pages. In comparison, I created 
 > a PDF out of the XForms 1.0 spec and got 127 pages. Given that WebForms is 
 > still under development and XForms is approved, one would expect some 
 > further growth, making the size of the two specs about the same.

I think you raise a valid point; ideally the specification will become
smaller rather than larger from now on. However, XForms has
dependencies on other specifications (XSD, XPath) which makes it more
complex than a page count seems. WF has similar dependencies on DOM
but this seems less scary since DOM is already deployed.

 > When I did a quick survey of features, I see major overlap. My conclusion 
 > is that WebForms to a large extent is simply just a competitive format with 
 > XForms. If you are going to add 100+ pages of incremental features to the 
 > browser world, of which a major portion has already been defined by the 
 > W3C, why not build from XForms, which is an approved standard 

HTML is also an approved standard. 

 > Perhaps Web Forms started out with the goal of doing something small as 
 > minor increments to existing HTML, but now it seems to have grown into a 
 > rather large beast of its own. Also, perhaps Web Forms started when XForms 
 > had little traction and therefore could be discounted, but in 2004 interest 
 > in XForms has picked up quite a bit.

Perhaps. Personally, I don't hear the thunder. 

-h&kon
              H?kon Wium Lie                          CTO ??e??
howcome at opera.com                  http://people.opera.com/howcome
Received on Thursday, 6 January 2005 22:45:51 UTC

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.3.1 : Monday, 13 April 2015 23:08:20 UTC