RE: [DOM4] Short and Efficent DOM Traversal

Cool to see my CSS Filter thing seems the less controversial part of the mix :-)

> > - a new 'iterateBackwards' boolean field on TreeWalker/NodeIterator 
> > that would make any ES iterator call previousNode() instead of 
> > nextNode() when computing the next iteration (to make navigation 
> > possible in both direction using ES iterators)
>
> Not quite.  Let a TreeWalker be an iterable (an object 
> capable of producing an iterator).  Give it two methods,
> nodes() and previousNodes().  Each return an ES iterator,
> starting from the TreeWalker's current nod, going either
> forwards or backwards in the DOM.  Then give it an 
> @@iterator attribute holding the nodes() method. 

I agree it provides a much better semantic and allow to create as many indepemdant iterators as needed but it also means I can't change the direction of progress during the iteration. Granted, if I want to do that, maybe for-of isn't the best option anyway and I can still use .nextNode() / .previousNode() manually like I do now. So, let it be that way.

For symmetry with the existing methods, I would call the two iterator-generating functions .nextNodes() and .previousNodes() whose .nextNodes() would have the newly defined [Iterator] attribute, but that's just my 2 cents ;-)

Received on Monday, 29 July 2013 02:28:39 UTC