Minutes for WCAG 2.0 Team B Telecon Meeting of 6-27-2007 ATTENDEES: Katie Haritos-Shea Sorcha Moore Tim Boland REGRETS: Gez Lemon AGENDA 1. Results/Responses to TEAM B SURVEY FOR JUNE 22. The June 22 WCAG Group meeting did not get to the Team B Survey questions to finalize, because time ran out. (http://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/teamb062206/results). We decide to address some of the comment in the survey in advance of July 29 meeting. Team B Survey for June 22: (http://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/teamb062206/results). Comment 465, 466, 545 - Wording of Success Criterion 4.2.1, 4.2.3 11 - 1 - 0 ACCEPTED? Assigned To: Gez Lemon OUTCOME: Action Item for Katie. Ask Gez Lemon to go back and see if Ben's comment is true about Gregg's question in the Survey. Comment 503 - Generalize SC 3.2.2 6 -5 - 1 Assigned To: Sorcha Moore OUTCOME: Action Item for Sorcha Moore. Sorcha will re-do proposal wording. Comment 543 - Is SC 3.1.6 needed for alphabetic languages 11 - 1 - 0 ACCEPTED? Assigned To: Sorcha Moore OUTCOME: Action Item for Sorcha Moore. Sorcha will re-do proposal wording. Comment 557 - Use of title attribute should be advisory 11 - 0 - 1 Assigned To: Loretta Guarino Reid OUTCOME: Action Item for Katie. Put Comment 557 on HOLD and assign to the key word 'User Agent'. Comment 597 - Benefit of SC 3.1.5 for the deaf 6 - 6 - 0 Assigned To: Loretta Guarino Reid OUTCOME: Action Item for Katie. Add new suggested wording, agreed on by team B meeting on 6-27-2006 to Comment 597 under Loretta's response. Comment 602- Alternate versions at lower reading level 11 - 1 - 0 ACCEPTED? Assigned To: Loretta Guarino Reid. OUTCOME: Action Item for Katie. Add Gregg's comment from survey to proposal in DB. Comment 606- Change of context 10 - 1 - 1 Assigned To: Sorcha Moore OUTCOME: Action Item for Sorcha Moore. Sorcha will re-do proposal wording. And she will put Comment 606 on HOLD and assign to the key word "Change of context". Comment 607- Change of context 7 - 4 - 1 Assigned To: Sorcha Moore OUTCOME: Action Item for Sorcha Moore. Sorcha will re-do proposal wording. And she will put Comment 607 on HOLD and assign to the key word "Change of context". Comment 619 - Mechanism 10 - 0 - 2 Assigned To: Sorcha Moore OUTCOME: Action Item for Sorcha Moore. Sorcha will re-do proposal wording. Comment 702- Links to areas of content 11 - 1 - 0 ACCEPTED? Assigned To: Loretta Guarino Reid OUTCOME: Action Item for Katie. Add Bens suggested sentence from survey to proposal in DB for Comment 702. Comment 734- Wording of SC 4.2.2 11 - 0 - 1 Assigned To: Loretta Guarino Reid OUTCOME: Action Item for Katie. Send email to Micheal Cooper to re-do resolution to Comment 734 as he objects in Survey and suggests that he will re-do it. Comment 750- SC 4.2.2 applies to which technologies? 10 - 0 - 2 Assigned To: Loretta Guarino Reid OUTCOME: Action Item for Katie. Assign keyword 'conformance' or 'not in baseline'. 2. OTHER COMMENTS DISCUSSED Comment LC-705 Document: Techniques Document Submitter: Chris Ridpath "Too broad and undefined." Assigned To: Loretta Guarino Reid OUTCOME: None. Comment LC-711 Document: Techniques Document Submitter: Chris Ridpath "The \"set of web units\" is not defined. Does this include every single page?" Assigned To: OUTCOME: Action Item for Tim Boland. He will put on this comment on HOLD and add to keyword 'web-units'. 3. COMMENTS ASSIGNED None on the call. Folks will send in the comments that they wish to address. Comment LC-701 Document: Techniques Document Submitter: Chris Ridpath "Confusing technique." Assigned To: Comment LC-703 Document: Techniques Document Submitter: Chris Ridpath "It's unclear how many are in a group." Assigned To: Comment LC-704 Document: Techniques Document Submitter: Chris Ridpath "The requirement for NOFRAMES has been dropped. Is this an oversight or is NOFRAMES really no longer necessary?" Assigned To: Comment LC-710 Document: Techniques Document Submitter: Chris Ridpath "Broaden the technique to include other actions that should not cause change of context." Assigned To: Comment LC-712 Document: WCAG 2.0 Guidelines Submitter: Jaakko Vilen "electronic banking accessibility, and have found that the link texts should be clearly descriptive..." Assigned To: Working Group Notes: [TEAMB] It is covered by 2.4.8, which is Level 3. (This isn't covered by 2.4.4 (since context may be required to interpret the link text for 2.4.4)) Comment LC-712 Document: WCAG 2.0 Guidelines Submitter: Jim Thatcher "Remove SC 2.4.4." Assigned To: 4. GOING TO SURVEY for June 29. NONE THIS WEEK Will do survey next week. 5. NEXT TEAM B MEETING Meeting date changed for next week because of US Holiday, 4th of July. Meeting Team B will meet next Wednesday (July 5). 17:00 UTC 10:00 AM Palo Alto 1:00 PM Boston 6:00 PM England, Ireland 2:00 AM (June 20) Japan Bridge: +1.617.761.6200 Passcode 92248# Irc.w3.org port 6665 #wcag-teamb ****************************************************************************************************************** FYI........... TEAM B is Responsible for: Introduction 2.4 [B] Provide mechanisms to help users find content, orient themselves within it, and navigate through it 3.1 [B] Make text content readable and understandable. 3.2 [B] Make the placement and functionality of content predictable. 4.2 [B] Ensure that content is accessible or provide an accessible alternative Team B Group: John Slatin (Stepping Back) Loretta Guarino Reid (Team Leader) Wendy (Stepping Down) Maybe Micheal now? Makoto UeKi Katie Haritos-Shea Tim Boland Sorcha Moore Gez Lemon ****************************************************************************************************************** Thanks............Sorcha and Katie. Katie Haritos-Shea ryladog@earthlink.net