- From: Detlev Fischer via WBS Mailer <webmaster@w3.org>
- Date: Mon, 30 Jun 2014 17:39:01 +0000
- To: public-wcag-em-comments@w3.org,shadi@w3.org,e.velleman@accessibility.nl
The following answers have been successfully submitted to 'Approval for publication of WCAG-EM 1.0 as a W3C Working Group Note' (public) for Detlev Fischer. > > --------------------------------- > Abstract > ---- > > > * (x) accept this section * ( ) accept this section with the following suggestions * ( ) I do not accept this section for the following reasons * ( ) I abstain (not vote) > > > --------------------------------- > Introduction > ---- > > > * (x) accept this section * ( ) accept this section with the following suggestions * ( ) I do not accept this section for the following reasons * ( ) I abstain (not vote) > > > --------------------------------- > Using This Methodology > ---- > > > * (x) accept this section * ( ) accept this section with the following suggestions * ( ) I do not accept this section for the following reasons * ( ) I abstain (not vote) > > > --------------------------------- > Scope of Applicability > ---- > > > * (x) accept this section * ( ) accept this section with the following suggestions * ( ) I do not accept this section for the following reasons * ( ) I abstain (not vote) > > > --------------------------------- > Step 1: Define the Evaluation Scope > ---- > > > * ( ) accept this section * ( ) accept this section with the following suggestions * ( ) I do not accept this section for the following reasons * ( ) I abstain (not vote) > > > --------------------------------- > Step 2: Explore the Target Website > ---- > > > * (x) accept this section * ( ) accept this section with the following suggestions * ( ) I do not accept this section for the following reasons * ( ) I abstain (not vote) > > > --------------------------------- > Step 3: Select a Representative Sample > ---- > > > * ( ) accept this section * (x) accept this section with the following suggestions * ( ) I do not accept this section for the following reasons * ( ) I abstain (not vote) Location: Step 3.b: Include a Randomly Selected Sample Priority: strong Current wording: "The number of web pages and web page states to randomly select is 10% of the structured sample selected through the previous steps, with a minimum of 5 instances of web pages and web page states." Suggested revisions:: * Amend the requirement of a minimum of 5 randomly selected instances of web pages and web page states to account for sites that will require a vera small sample. (Possibly in a note.) * Clarify what selecting a random sample of states means when creating a sample for web apps. Rationale: For some sites, the page sample can be very small: think of a blog which uses just one template and contains only text. Such a blog may just have the default view, a selected blog entry, and maybe search results page. A minimum of 5 randomly selected pages / states does not make sense in such a case. For web apps, it is not clear how the evaluator should select states randomly. I can think of no procedure as there is usually not a list of URLs, search hits or similar to work from. > > > --------------------------------- > Step 4: Audit the Selected Sample > ---- > > > * (x) accept this section * ( ) accept this section with the following suggestions * ( ) I do not accept this section for the following reasons * ( ) I abstain (not vote) > > > --------------------------------- > Step 5: Report the Evaluation Findings > ---- > > > * (x) accept this section * ( ) accept this section with the following suggestions * ( ) I do not accept this section for the following reasons * ( ) I abstain (not vote) > > > --------------------------------- > Remaing Comments > ---- > Provide any remaining comments that you may have. > > Comments: > > These answers were last modified on 30 June 2014 at 17:37:35 U.T.C. > by Detlev Fischer > Answers to this questionnaire can be set and changed at https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/1/WCAG-EM-20140623/ until 2014-06-30. Regards, The Automatic WBS Mailer
Received on Monday, 30 June 2014 17:39:03 UTC