Re: TTML2 and questionnaire for Security and Privacy; for review.

Hi,

Bellow are latest updated responses for review regarding TTML2, to 
answer the Self-Review Questionnaire: Security and Privacy
https://www.w3.org/TR/security-privacy-questionnaire/

I have incorporated Mike's comments and the discussion during our last 
telecon.

I have look for security issue in SMIL
https://www.w3.org/TR/2008/REC-SMIL3-20081201/

I couln't find any security issues mentioned.

Looking at SVG 1.1 (Second Edition)
https://www.w3.org/TR/SVG/single-page.html

There is a section about security issues
https://www.w3.org/TR/SVG/single-page.html#chapter-mimereg
Security considerations:

[ ...
  Several SVG elements may cause arbitrary URIs to be referenced. In 
this case, the security issues of [RFC3986], section 7, should be 
considered.

In common with HTML, SVG documents may reference external media such as 
images, audio, video, style sheets, and scripting languages. Scripting 
languages are executable content. In this case, the security 
considerations in the Media Type registrations for those formats shall 
apply.

..]

Should we consider someting similar  for 3.6 question ?



Thierry

----------------------------------------

Questions to Consider:
3.1 Does this specification deal with personally-identifiable information?
--> NO it doesn't.

3.2 Does this specification deal with high-value data?
--> NO it doesn't.

3.3 Does this specification introduce new state for an origin that
persists across browsing sessions?
--> NO it doesn't.

3.4 Does this specification expose persistent, cross-origin state to the
web?
--> NO it doesn't.

3.5 Does this specification expose any other data to an origin that it
doesn’t currently have access to?
--> NO it doesn't.

3.6 Does this specification enable new script execution/loading
mechanisms?
-->  This question as worded is ambiguous to us; is it only about script 
loading and script execution ?
In our case, a TTML2 document in which a change in the value of an 
externally passed in parameter or a media query (for example) may cause 
a modification of behavior, and this may lead to the loading of external 
resources including audio, images etc, though excluding scripts. We do 
not consider "condition" mechanism to be a scripting language.
TTML2 allows loading of resources, just not scripts, and has fetch 
semantics by the introduction of external resource loading. It also 
allows the addition of links on spans that can have hyperlinks.

Futhermore <set> is arguably a (very specialized) script?
Tthe animation vocabulary is declarative rather than procedural, it has 
generally been considered non-script (in SMIL, SVG, etc).
@@@@@@@@@@@@@ to be finalized @@@@

3.7 Does this specification allow an origin access to a user’s location?
--> NO it doesn't.

3.8 Does this specification allow an origin access to sensors on a
user’s device?
--> NO it doesn't.

3.9 Does this specification allow an origin access to aspects of a
user’s local computing environment?
--> NO it doesn't.

3.10 Does this specification allow an origin access to other devices?
--> NO it doesn't.

3.11 Does this specification allow an origin some measure of control
over a user agent’s native UI?
--> NO it doesn't.

3.12 Does this specification expose temporary identifiers to the web?
--> NO it doesn't.

3.13 Does this specification distinguish between behavior in first-party
and third-party contexts?
--> NO it doesn't.

3.14 How should this specification work in the context of a user agent’s 
"incognito" mode?
--> This specification has no impact on any incognito mode since the 
answer to all the questions about exposing details to origins are "No".

3.15 Does this specification persist data to a user’s local device?
--> User agents may choose to cache referenced external resources; this
implementation detail is not covered by this specification and the
specification makes no explicit requirement for caching or non-caching 
of any external resource.

3.16 Does this specification have a "Security Considerations" and
"Privacy Considerations" section?
--> YES it does. See the media type registration which is an integral 
part of it.


http://www.iana.org/assignments/media-types/application/ttml+xml

@@@@
https://www.w3.org/TR/ttml-profile-registry/


3.17 Does this specification allow downgrading default security
characteristics?
--> NO it doesn't.

--------------------------------------------

Received on Monday, 17 October 2016 16:00:31 UTC