Re: Audio logs for IG & WG telecons?

On 09/05/2014 01:20 AM, Harry Halpin wrote:
> On 09/01/2014 10:40 PM, ☮ elf Pavlik ☮ wrote:
>> Hello,
> 
>> I would like to propose recording and publishing audio from IG &
>> WG telecons. Written minutes sometimes don't capture the
>> conversation very well and having audio available can make it
>> easier for everyone interested to follow the work. I would find
>> it useful especially for WG which to my understanding has vary
>> restrictive requirements for joining (IMO currently also not very
>> clearly explained).
> 
>> Web Payments CG records and publishes telecons in very nice way:
>>  https://web-payments.org/minutes/
> 
> Groups can make their own decisions on this front, historically
> that's audio recordings are not done due to the fact that people
> may make mistakes speaking they want corrected and so members, in
> particular companies, feel comfortable disclosing informally things
> they may not want formally disclosed. The Web Payments CG seem to
> have about 5 people on telcos and one small business doing
> implementing, so it's probably not an issue for them.
Ok, I understand your points!


> 
> Note that also your Invited Expert application was approved.
> However, we are not very restrictive but we do require chair or
> staff approval.
Yes, it made possible for me to join the WG telecon just few hours
later :) Much appreciated!


> 
> Re IEs in general for at least implementation-focused WGs it makes 
> sense to let only people who are building systems or who have
> built systems into the WG given its focus on implementation.
> Otherwise, as we've seen in quite a few Community Groups, the
> discussion gets side-tracked rather easily from their schedule. The
> Community Groups of course still exist for general discussion.
Soon I would like to post invitation to compile a wiki page to clearly
explain which concerns belong to which group. At this moment thinking
mostly of Social WG, Social IG and Federated Social Web CG.

> 
> 
> 
> 
>> Could we get something working already for meetings in next two 
>> days?
> 
> Unless the IG or WG explicitly asks for this, the W3C does do it
> by default.
I understand you meant: "W3C does NOT do it by default"

> 
> cheers, harry
> 
>> Thanks!
Thanks++

> 
>

Received on Friday, 5 September 2014 10:11:55 UTC