29 Jan 2009

See also: IRC log


John, MSM, Ginny, Kumar, Len, Sandy, Kirk
John Arwe
Kirk Wilson




Approval of minutes 1/22

<lencharest> http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-sml/2009Jan/att-0058/20090122-sml-minutes.html

RESOLUTION: No objections to accepting minutes

No Change to CG

We are not attending F2F week of Feb 23

Action Items

MSM hopes to have action items closed by EOB tomorrow

Except for AI 190 (lax fallback use case) will not be completed. John will close this AI.

Change of Telecon Time

We will see what progress is made today to decide whether we should meet again on this coming Monday.

Farewell to MSM

Tomorrow will be MSM's last day as a member of the Team.

John expressed appreciation for MSM contributions to the working group.

MSM expressed belief that Henry will do well, and we will be happy with Henry as well.

New Work

No new bugs

MSM reports that issue regarding the length of the code lines as been resolved. That bug can be closed.

Kumar: Will correct documents to "PR" version.

Ginny: There is nothing left to fix with latest correction. Kumar can go ahead and fix the document.

John: Points out the SML-IF doc has missing schema (just xi:include); SML is missing copyright date.

<johnarwe_> A. SML-IF Schema

<johnarwe_> <xi:include></xi:include>

<johnarwe_> B. Localization of IF Identity Sample (Non-Normative)

<MSM> http://dev.w3.org/cvsweb/~checkout~/2007/xml/sml/build/sml.html?content-type=text/html;%20charset=utf-8#SML_schema

Ginny: Editors need to check that schemas are present when they do a rebuild.

Ginny will close 5492. Change target to PR.

Issue 6260: http://www.w3.org/Bugs/Public/show_bug.cgi?id=6260

Kumar will review this issue.

MSM: Changes 1, 2, 3 are now incorporated in SML & SML-IF
... Change 4 is no longer necessary.

John: Reports he has covered change 5 in his draft.

Kumar: Reports that he will cover change 6. Kumar will close bug.

Issue 5680: http://www.w3.org/Bugs/Public/show_bug.cgi?id=5680

Ginny has provided diff file.

Len: Appendix F, offset paragraph, #1, too many "is"s. Ginny will remove one of the "is"s.

Kumar: Recommends using "PR" when checking this in to invoke the PR rules.

John: Agrees,

MSM: Wishes there were a better solution to this problem within W3C.

Ginny: Ch
... Checking this in, Feb 12, 2009, with "PR".

John: Any further changes to 5680? Any objections to marking 5680 as Editorial? Any need for "Needs Review"?

RESOLUTION: No Objections to any of these proposals. Ginny updates the issue.

Review of PR Transition Request Draft

<johnarwe_> http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-sml/2009Jan/att-0077/SML_PR_Transition_request.htm

John: URIs refer to dates that we expect.

John: On MSMs recommendation, John needs to add URI to current version.

RESOLUTION: Consensus without objection to the proposed publication date.

John reviews text and any changes to the text.

scribe: Implementation Information is a new section. No comments on this section.
... Document Status has changes. Reviews changes.
... Editors are allowed to readd the sentence that is striked-out if it is necessary to get the PubRules to run.

Kumar: Suggests moving sentences. John suggests moving Teal paragraph after "(XML) Activity"

RESOLUTION: No further changes appear to be necessary. Consensus on content of the Transition Request.

Implementation Reports


Feature Implementation Report:

<johnarwe_> http://www.w3.org/XML/SML/SMLPRFeatureImplementationReport.html

MSM: Suggests using color backgrounds for Results.

<johnarwe_> impl results: file:///C:/ARWE/Standards/SML/Temp/SMLPRTestCaseImplementationResults.html

Implementation Results

<johnarwe_> http://www.w3.org/XML/SML/SMLPRTestCaseImplementationResults.html

John: Yellow means the tests are not committed by COSMOS to CVS, but they have been run by COSMOS.

No further comments on Implementation Results

SML Diffs Affecting Schemas

<johnarwe_> SML diffs: http://dev.w3.org/cvsweb/~checkout~/2007/xml/sml/extra/sml-diff-between-CR-and-PR.html?content-type=text/html;%20charset=utf-8

MSM: Points out that Appendix B of SML needs to be run through style sheet.

John: Notes that the namespaces names have disappeared from the schema in Appendix A. MSM will try to fix. (Editors may need to manually fix this.)

RESOLUTION: No other problems in the SML spec.

<johnarwe_> SMLIF diffs http://dev.w3.org/cvsweb/~checkout~/2007/xml/sml/extra/sml-if-diff-between-CR-and-PR.html?content-type=text/html;%20charset=utf-8

John: Same namespace binding issue on the SML-IF schema.

RESOLUTION: No other problems in the SML-IF schema.

Telecon this Monday 02/02

Possible topic: Review of the two Notes.

NOTE: Kirk expresses regrets regarding telecon on 02/02.

John: Team is not ready to review Notes on Monday, given the need to do final editing.

DECISION: Cancel 02/02 telecon. Resume 02/09. Topic: Discuss changes to Notes.

John: Because of schedule transition meeting with Director, we may need to push out the publication date to the 19th.

RESOLUTION: No objections to allowing this change of date of publication date.

Len: Will delete original Word docs from CVS, not part of revision history.
... No objections noted.

Adjournment: 3:38 pm ET

Summary of Action Items

[End of minutes]

Updated Scribe List

Last Scribe Date        Member Name         Regrets pending 
2008-05-22              Lynn, James         Until further notice 
2008-10-29              Pandit, Kumar       
2009-01-08              Smith, Virginia     
2009-01-15              Gao, Sandy       
2008-01-22              Charest, Len               
2009-01-29              Wilson, Kirk         02/02         
Exempt                  Arwe, John 
Exempt                  Henry Thompson