David, The Primer is ready for you to review at: http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/BestPractices/HTML/2006-04-24-rdfa-primer (you'll need a Mozilla-based browser to see it, as it's XML with XSLT). Your comments on our WD#1 (before the URI information resource issue) are at [1]. I wanted to let you know how we addressed these comments in WD#2 to help your review: > 1. Sec 3.1, where "dc:" first appears, it would be good to mention > (forward reference) that Sec 4.4 will explain how the dc: prefix is > defined. The new Section 2 should address these introductory issues better. Let us know if this is still problematic. > 2. Sec 3.2, I suggest changing: > [[ > Using the rel attribute, one can easily update this HTML to include an > RDF/A statement:" > ]] > to mention that rel expects a sibling href attribute. Perhaps > something > like: > [[ > Using the rel attribute (which expects a sibling href attribute), one > can easily update this HTML to include an RDF/A statement:" > ]] > > Also add something like the following just before the paragraph that > begins "Similarly, Shutr may want to give its users": > [[ > Because the rel attribute was used, the RDF property value came > from the > href attribute instead of coming from the body of the <a> element. > ]] The new phrasing and introduction should also improve the situation there, and there's now similar language to what you suggested. > 3. Sec 3.2, next-to-last paragraph, the word "is" is repeated,: > once in > italics and once plain. Nice catch, fixed! > Sec 4.1: I started wondering: Does XMLLiteral trim leading and > trailing > whitespace? Maybe it would be good to mention how/where this is > treated. We haven't fixed this issue yet. > 4. Sec 4.2, first paragraph: s/from a parent/from a parent or > ancestor/ fixed. > 5. Sec 4.3: Extra space before ":" after "which behave in a special > way". fixed. > 6. Sec 4.4: I suggest putting the paragraph break before "A CURIE, > e.g., > dc:title" instead of before "We now address URI duplication". fixed according to your suggestion. -BenReceived on Wednesday, 26 April 2006 14:31:45 GMT
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.2.0+W3C-0.50 : Tuesday, 8 January 2008 14:15:01 GMT