W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > public-powderwg@w3.org > December 2008

Last call comments: GROUPS and FORMAL

From: Hammond, Tony <t.hammond@nature.com>
Date: Fri, 05 Dec 2008 14:52:23 +0000
To: <public-powderwg@w3.org>
Message-ID: <C55EF0A7.163E6%t.hammond@nature.com>

Hi:

Late to comment and not had time to fully investigate in detail. So
apologies if I have not appreciated a rationale already given. But I'm
having a hard time accepting some of the regex'es which seem to depart from
Rabin's work.

GROUPS

* Sect 2.1

Minor point but in the component diagram the "scheme" brace over extends and
includes the colon char (":") which is a delimiter and NOT part of the
scheme.

* Table 4

I do not follow rationale for the regex's in the table. I agree with Rabin's
regex given earlier in Sect. 2.1.

Specifically I do not see why "\/\/" are listed as required components in
the regex which they're clearly not in Rabin's and clearly not required in a
generic URI.

E.g. the initial "schemes" regex is given as

    ^var\:/\/\/

The "\/\/" have nothing to do with URI scheme or delimiting URI scheme. That
job is done by the colon char (":") alone.

Likewise for remaining components, why is the "\/\/" exposed as a required
pattern when it should be part of the optional authority component?

* Sect 2.1.2

Again the template regex departs from Rabin's and makes the "\/\/" pattern
required. Which it shouldn't be for a generic URI.

FORMAL

* Sect 4.2, Text
* Table 3

Again regex has "\/\/" a required pattern. Surely that's not a requisite for
generic URI processing?

I see the rationale for including the "\/\/" in Examples 4-1, 4-2 where
their presence can be inferred form the "<includehosts>" element, and in
Examples 4-3, 4-4 from the "<includeuripattern>" content.

Cheers,

Tony



********************************************************************************   
DISCLAIMER: This e-mail is confidential and should not be used by anyone who is
not the original intended recipient. If you have received this e-mail in error
please inform the sender and delete it from your mailbox or any other storage
mechanism. Neither Macmillan Publishers Limited nor any of its agents accept
liability for any statements made which are clearly the sender's own and not
expressly made on behalf of Macmillan Publishers Limited or one of its agents.
Please note that neither Macmillan Publishers Limited nor any of its agents
accept any responsibility for viruses that may be contained in this e-mail or
its attachments and it is your responsibility to scan the e-mail and 
attachments (if any). No contracts may be concluded on behalf of Macmillan 
Publishers Limited or its agents by means of e-mail communication. Macmillan 
Publishers Limited Registered in England and Wales with registered number 785998 
Registered Office Brunel Road, Houndmills, Basingstoke RG21 6XS   
********************************************************************************
Received on Friday, 5 December 2008 14:53:12 GMT

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.2.0+W3C-0.50 : Monday, 7 December 2009 10:42:13 GMT