POE/ODRL Validator page issue

Hi Victor,

thanks for numbering all the items on the POE/ODRL Validation page -
https://www.w3.org/2016/poe/wiki/Validation 

 

Now I have added them to the Implementation Report sheet at
<https://goo.gl/iXnonW> https://goo.gl/iXnonW

And noticed a few issues:

*	Items V11 . V15 are about the role of a profile in a Policy and the
headlines say ". only ODRL . can be used". But: this must be ". only ODRL
Core . can be used" as we have two different ODRL vocabularies, Core and
Common. (The internal text mentions this in some cases correctly, in some
not.)
Please make the need for ODRL Core visible.
*	A very special case is V 13. In absence of profile, only ODRL left
operands can be used
In this case even using ODRL Core will not help as the Core vocabulary does
not include any leftOperands = a profile is a mandatory requirement for
adding a Constraint to a Rule.
Therefore the heading must be 
In absence of profile, no Constraints can be used (leftOperand defined by
the profile is required)
*	In this context V14 and V15 is questionable: without profile no
Constraint - therefore the existence of an operator cannot be checked and a
Logical Constraint cannot point to any constraints.

 

Ok, that's it.

Please let me know about fixing this as I should update the Report sheet.

 

Thanks,

Michael

 

 

Received on Wednesday, 27 September 2017 17:18:10 UTC