Re: [poe] Specifications of includedIn and implies need improvements

The history of this mini-tree in ODRL 2.1 is:
Present = to perform or exhibit an Asset to an audience.
Print =  to print an Asset onto paper or to create a hard copy.
Play = to perform an audio Asset to an audience.
Display = to display the visual media Asset to an audience or the public.

Present encompassed that an audience can experience any kind of presentation of an asset. Frankly the focus was set on a media asset - the definition did not tell that unfortunately. (Display of a database would be interesting ;-)
And print provided an experience by a hard copy, play an audio experience, and display a visual (potentially plus audio) experience.
I agree that print does not fit very well as sibling of play and display as it is in fact more a subclass of display.

So I suggest as definitions
Present: to perform or exhibit a media Asset to an audience + IncludedIn Use
Play: to perform an audio media asset + IncludedIn Present
Display:  to perform a visual media asset with an optional audio media asset (Note: covers both still and moving images, possibly with audio) + IncludedIn Present
Print: to perform any fitting media asset as hard copy + IncludedIn Present or Use

-- 
GitHub Notification of comment by nitmws
Please view or discuss this issue at https://github.com/w3c/poe/issues/192#issuecomment-308760987 using your GitHub account

Received on Thursday, 15 June 2017 14:59:47 UTC