- From: Lorrie Cranor <lorrie@research.att.com>
- Date: Fri, 16 May 2003 12:04:08 -0400
- To: public-p3p-spec@w3.org
16 May 2003 User Agent Task Force Call Participants Lorrie Cranor - AT&T Research Giles Hogben - JRC Jeremy Epling - Microsoft Brooks Dobbs - DoubleClick Ari Schwartz - CDT We discussed the question of whether to aim for a single translation of all P3P vocabulary elements or multiple translations. The consensus of the group was that we should aim for a single translation. In the process of doing this we may come up with multiple alternatives that we want to vet with lawyers and/or test in the usability lab, but at the end of the process we hope to have a single translation for each term. ACTION: Lorrie, Jeremy, and anyone else who wants to, use one of the translation documents as a starting point and make revisions based on feedback received so far and send to group by 23 May. The group will then use these revised documents as a starting point for further discussion of each element. We discussed the question of whether we should have guidelines on completeness of translations, including display of human-readable fields and specific data elements (as opposed to categories). The consensus was that we should not recommend that user agents display all possible fields in a P3P policy, but we should have guidelines to ensure that critical information gets displayed. ACTION: All TF members should send to the mailing list by 23 May proposed guidelines related to what elements need to be included in a translation. We discussed whether we wanted to make recommendations on issues that go beyond displaying policy translations, for example guidelines on saving and printing policies, checking the sanity of compact policies, etc. The consensus was that we do want to try draft guidelines in this area. ACTION: All TF members should send to the mailing list by 23 May other proposed user agent guidelines. ACTION: Brooks will try to enumerate impossible combinations of tokens in compact policies Our next call will be Tuesday, May 27 at 11am US Eastern.
Received on Friday, 16 May 2003 12:02:49 UTC