Re: The MusicXML challenge and Chords - MusicXML is Excellent!

Thanks to Andrew for the Raindrop-example. Interesting to see more 
examples. Also if there are
MusicXML files for the tunes. The Raindrop-prelude is interesting 
because it is intuitive, while
the correct written notes are difficult to read - if the attached file 
is right.

Mogens

PS: I get more and more convinced that the idea of making <duration> a 
total would make notes unambiguous. There will be some preconditions. I 
think I can make a mathematical proof.

PS: Midi is ambiguous - due to the division there will always be small 
differences in the delta-values. The delta must be considered
rational numbers - like floating point. Also other values differ with 
minor changes.  And much more ....

On 2015-11-02 17:59, Joe Berkovitz wrote:
> Andrew, thanks for sharing this extremely useful example (Don Byrd is 
> an old collaborator and advisor of mine, by the way). I think this is 
> a perfect way to frame one of the key questions about use cases that 
> confronts this group.
>
> ...
On Mon, Oct 26, 2015 at 11:30 AM, Andrew Hankinson 
<andrew.hankinson@gmail.com <mailto:andrew.hankinson@gmail.com>> wrote:
>
>     ....
>     If you want to build a printable representation, a better option
>     is to use SVG or Postscript. Or, if you want an unambiguous timing
>     model, use MIDI or OSC.
>
>