W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > public-html@w3.org > January 2012

Re: Revised Timeline and New Bug Priority Policy

From: Sam Ruby <rubys@intertwingly.net>
Date: Mon, 23 Jan 2012 11:51:31 -0500
Message-ID: <4F1D9013.7070402@intertwingly.net>
To: public-html@w3.org
On 01/19/2012 12:47 PM, Richard Schwerdtfeger wrote:
> Paul,
>
> The timeline is unrealistic. The chairs have a drop dead date for change
> proposals on February 11. Following that you have given until March 10
> to have all counter proposals in. There are a lot of issues open wrt.
> accessibility and it is inconceivable that all counter proposals will be
> submitted and reviewed with responses in a month. I do not think this is
> fair to the editor or the people working on the accessibility change
> proposals. As it is, this is right in the middle of:
>
> - CSUN - the largest technical accessibility conference in the U.S..
> Many people are presenting here, networking, and meeting with customers
> - SXSW Interactive - A number of us are presenting on accessibility -
> including canvas
> - WAI-ARIA Face to face meeting in Austin to get it through Candidate
> Recommendation
>
> It is not just the fact that we are attending the conference but we are
> also preparing for and traveling to them. Also, we all have our regular
> jobs which is not totally dedicated to W3C activities.
>
> Please reconsider the time line.

If you would like us to consider a change, making a concrete proposal 
would be helpful.  Additionally, I will suggest that asking for a 
limited extension for specific issues is more likely to be successful 
than a blanket request that applies to all issues.

If it helps, I've included at the bottom of this note a history of all 
of the issues in RAISED status (i.e., ones without a change proposal). 
The underlying bugs have all been open since the summer.  Some have been 
open since 2010.

The plan is to mark those issues for which we do not receive a Change 
Proposal as POSTPONED.

> Rich
>
> Rich Schwerdtfeger

ISSUE-193: inaccessible-example
2011-06-23 bug 13023 Reported
2011-08-10 bug 13023 Resolved: WONTFIX
2012-01-13 issue 193 Raised

ISSUE-194: full-transcript
2011-06-16 bug 12964 Reported
2011-08-11 bug 12964 Resolved: NEEDSINFO
2011-10-13 bug 12964 Reopened
2011-12-02 bug 12964 Resolved: NEEDSINFO
2012-01-13 bug 12964 TrackerRequest
2012-01-13 issue 194 Raised

ISSUE-195: form-http-req
2010-09-21 bug 10671 Reported
2010-09-30 bug 10671 Resolved: FIXED
2011-03-31 bug 10671 Reopened
2011-12-02 bug 10671 Resolved: WONTFIX
2012-01-12 bug 10671 TrackerRequest
2012-01-14 issue 195 Raised

ISSUE-196: ua-http-resp-handling
2010-09-21 bug 10671 Reported
2010-09-30 bug 10671 Resolved: FIXED
2011-03-31 bug 10671 Reopened
2011-12-02 bug 10671 Resolved: WONTFIX
2012-01-12 bug 10671 TrackerRequest
2012-01-14 issue 196 Raised

ISSUE-197: accept-file-ext
2010-12-06 bug 11482 Reported
2011-02-16 bug 11482 Resolved: WONTFIX
2011-10-14 bug 11482 Reopened
2012-01-14 bug 11482 TrackerRequest
2012-01-14 issue 197 Raised
2012-01-18 bug 11482 Resolved: LATER

ISSUE-198: innerHTML-patent-policy
2010-10-13 bug 11024 Reported
2010-10-13 bug 11024 Resolved: INVALID
2012-01-16 issue 198 Raised

ISSUE-199: aria-processing
2011-01-27 bug 11891 Reported
2011-01-27 bug 11892 Reported
2011-01-27 bug 11893 Reported
2011-05-03 bug 11892 Resolved: NEEDSINFO
2011-08-12 bug 11893 Resolved: NEEDSINFO
2011-08-16 bug 11891 Resolved: NEEDSINFO
2012-01-13 bug 11893 TrackerRequest
2012-01-16 issue 199 Raised

ISSUE-200: legend-placement
2011-05-31 bug 12834 Reported
2011-08-14 bug 12834 Resolved: NEEDSINFO
2011-08-15 bug 12834 Reopened
2011-12-02 bug 12834 Resolved: NEEDSINFO
2011-12-03 bug 12834 Reopened
2011-12-04 bug 12834 Resolved: WONTFIX
2011-12-04 bug 12834 Reopened
2012-01-13 bug 12834 TrackerRequest
2012-01-16 issue 200 Raised
2012-01-18 bug 12834 Resolved: LATER

ISSUE-201: canvas-fallback
2011-07-07 bug 13176 Reported
2011-07-07 bug 13181 Reported
2011-07-12 bug 13176 Priority: P1
2011-07-13 bug 13181 Priority: P1
2011-09-21 bug 13176 Resolved: WONTFIX
2011-09-22 bug 13176 Reopened
2012-01-11 bug 13181 TrackerRequest
2012-01-11 bug 13176 TrackerRequest
2012-01-16 issue 201 Raised
2012-01-18 bug 13181 Resolved: LATER
2012-01-18 bug 13176 Resolved: LATER

ISSUE-202: figcaption-words
2011-08-03 bug 13651 Reported
2011-08-06 bug 13651 Resolved: WONTFIX
2011-12-14 bug 13651 TrackerRequest
2012-01-16 issue 202 Raised

ISSUE-203: media-descriptions
2011-03-03 bug 12228 Reported
2011-05-26 bug 12794 Reported
2011-11-24 bug 12228 Resolved: NEEDSINFO
2011-12-02 bug 12794 Resolved: NEEDSINFO
2012-01-13 bug 12228 Reopened
2012-01-13 bug 12794 Reopened
2012-01-13 bug 12228 Resolved: WORKSFORME
2012-01-13 bug 12794 Resolved: WONTFIX
2012-01-14 bug 12228 TrackerRequest
2012-01-14 bug 12794 TrackerRequest
2012-01-19 issue 203 Raised
Received on Monday, 23 January 2012 16:52:02 UTC

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.3.1 : Monday, 29 September 2014 09:39:29 UTC