- From: Eva Blomqvist <evabl444@gmail.com>
- Date: Mon, 13 Jan 2014 09:16:28 +0100
- To: public-emergency@w3.org
- Message-ID: <52D3A0DC.4020409@gmail.com>
I'm in favour of a google doc as well. And for the topic, no, I think it needs to be more general, right? /Eva On 13/1/2014 5:49 , Carsten Keßler wrote: > Concerning the 'weapon of choice' to write the paper, I'm not sure the > wiki is the best option. It's public (which may be fine), but it only > allows one person at a time to edit the document, and wiki syntax is > probably also another small barrier if we want to get to a result > quickly. I'd go with a google doc and copy the contents over to the > wiki once we have submitted the paper. > > Concerning Joseph's mail, I did not think this paper was going to be > about HXL, or did I miss anything? > > Talk to you tomorrow! > Carsten > > > > Am 12.01.2014 um 18:12 schrieb Joseph Pollack > <josephrichardpollack@gmail.com <mailto:josephrichardpollack@gmail.com>>: > >> Dear HXL, >> >> Great to see such renewed energy going into this! Below I propose a >> series of ways to present HXL’s position in the forrest of >> integration / information layers. It’s not meant to be an exhaustive >> selection of positioning methods, instead this presents some ways >> that Joseph thinks are promising & concise. >> >> Comparison Matrix – analysis of differentiation >> >> X >> >> >> >> *IEE 802.11n* >> >> >> >> *OASIS-CAP&UIMA* >> >> >> >> *WSDL & SOAP* >> >> >> >> *W3C EIIF* >> >> >> >> *EDXL* >> >> >> >> *IPAWS* >> >> >> >> *AMIGO* >> >> >> >> *HXL* >> >> *IEE 802.11n* >> >> >> >> *x* >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> *OASIS-CAP&UIMA* >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> *x* >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> *WSDL & SOAP* >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> *x* >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> *W3C EIIF* >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> *x* >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> *EDXL* >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> *x* >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> *IPAWS* >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> *x* >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> *AMIGO* >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> *x* >> >> >> >> ** >> >> *HXL* >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> ** >> >> >> >> *X* >> >> ** >> >> This comparison matrix would be used to describe how each information >> layer is different to the next. >> >> >> >> *Summary of HXL and its configuration* >> >> *Representation* >> >> >> >> *Organizing Vision* >> >> >> >> *Key Functionality* >> >> >> >> *Type/Scope* >> >> >> >> *Value Added* >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> These are (some of) the dimensions that will need to be introduced in >> order to present HXL >> >> >> >> *HXL Participation and Operator Analysis* >> >> *Partners* >> >> >> >> ** >> >> *Number of Participants* >> >> >> >> ** >> >> *Diffusion* >> >> >> >> ** >> >> *Openness * >> >> >> >> ** >> >> *Operator of the Platform* >> >> >> >> ** >> >> *Ownership / Funder / Sponsor* >> >> >> >> ** >> >> *Ratio of “Developers” to End-Users* >> >> >> >> *Direction of Relationships* >> >> >> >> Horizontal >> >> *Governance Structure* >> >> >> >> Network >> >> *Power, dependency* >> >> >> >> Pooled >> >> *Trading mechanism* >> >> >> >> Matching >> >> These are the dimensions that are required to satisfactorily >> introduce the HXL group. >> >> >> >> *HXL Area of Application and integration* >> >> *Supported Phases* >> >> >> >> Activation and information phase >> >> *Functional scope* >> >> >> >> Resource and activity tracking >> >> *Number of application areas* >> >> >> >> 2 >> >> *Competitive Advantage* >> >> >> >> *Geographic Focus* >> >> >> >> Virtual, international >> >> *Industry focus* >> >> >> >> Humanitarian >> >> *Potential for Integration * >> >> >> >> These are (some) dimensions that I think would summarise the >> application potential of HXL satisfactorily. >> >> >> >> Looking forward to HXL2014! It's a priviledge to be a witness to the >> snowballing of HXL! >> >> >> Warm Regards, >> >> >> -Joseph. >> >> >> >> On Sun, Jan 12, 2014 at 1:13 PM, Bart van Leeuwen >> <bart_van_leeuwen@netage.nl <mailto:bart_van_leeuwen@netage.nl>> wrote: >> >> Hi all >> >> If we produce something as group, whey don't we use the Wiki for >> that ? >> The W3C provides us with these facilities, so lets use them >> >> Met Vriendelijke Groet / With Kind Regards >> Bart van Leeuwen >> >> ############################################################## >> # twitter: @semanticfire >> # netage.nl <http://netage.nl> >> # http://netage.nl <http://netage.nl/> >> # Enschedepad 76 >> # 1324 GJ Almere >> # The Netherlands >> # tel. +31(0)36-5347479 <tel:%2B31%280%2936-5347479> >> ############################################################## >> >> >> >> From: Hemant Purohit <hemant@knoesis.org >> <mailto:hemant@knoesis.org>> >> To: Kauppinen Tomi <tomi.kauppinen@aalto.fi >> <mailto:tomi.kauppinen@aalto.fi>> >> Cc: Carsten Kessler <carsten.kessler@hunter.cuny.edu >> <mailto:carsten.kessler@hunter.cuny.edu>>, >> "public-emergency@w3.org <mailto:public-emergency@w3.org>" >> <public-emergency@w3.org <mailto:public-emergency@w3.org>> >> Date: 12-01-2014 01:34 >> Subject: Re: Next call >> ------------------------------------------------------------------------ >> >> >> >> Thanks, Tomi and Eva. I think google doc can be easy to >> collaborate in short time for all without any learning curve, so >> we can opt for that. In the Monday meeting, we can settle it >> down. Say? >> >> Best, >> Hemant >> >> >> On Fri, Jan 10, 2014 at 4:33 AM, Kauppinen Tomi >> <_tomi.kauppinen@aalto.fi_ <mailto:tomi.kauppinen@aalto.fi>> wrote: >> Happy New Year! >> >> @Hemant: good starting point for the short paper to take those >> (and other) notes. How shall we proceed? I am a big fan of online >> latex tools (like writelatex) for collaborative work but I am ok >> with any other solution (e.g. dropbox or google docs). Any opinions? >> >> Best, >> Tomi >> >> On Jan 9, 2014, at 9:50 PM, Hemant Purohit wrote: >> >> > Happy New Year to all :) Good to fix the time now to be more >> regular! >> > Re short paper, last bit was left at the comparison of the >> existing standards and showing the gap, while informing ISCRAM >> community about this group's initiative and mission statement, >> especially the bridge between plain data organization-centric >> approach to practical usability-centric approach aspect in >> standardization. The last group call minutes were noted here: >> _http://www.w3.org/community/emergency/wiki/Group_call_on_Nov_27,_2013_ >> > >> > Cheers, >> > Hemant >> > >> > >> > >> > On Thu, Jan 9, 2014 at 1:59 PM, Carsten Kessler >> <_carsten.kessler@hunter.cuny.edu_ >> <mailto:carsten.kessler@hunter.cuny.edu>> wrote: >> > Dear all, >> > >> > happy new year! It's been a while since our doodle poll, and >> Mondays >> > at 4PM CET/10AM EST is one of the favorites, so we'll have our >> > bi-weekly calls on Mondays for the time being. We'll start next >> week, >> > so mark your calendars. >> > >> > One urgent thing to discuss is whether we want to submit a >> short paper >> > to ISCRAM. In fact, we should be starting the discussion about this >> > right now via email, since the deadline is January 20th. >> > >> > Cheers, >> > Carsten >> > >> > --- >> > Carsten Kessler – _http://carsten.io_ <http://carsten.io/> >> > Center for Advanced Research of Spatial Information – >> _http://carsilab.org_ <http://carsilab.org/> >> > Department of Geography >> > Hunter College – CUNY >> > >> > 695 Park Avenue >> > New York, NY-10065 >> > >> > _carsten.kessler@hunter.cuny.edu_ >> <mailto:carsten.kessler@hunter.cuny.edu> >> > _+1 (212) 560-3591_ <tel:%2B1%20%28212%29%20560-3591> >> > >> > >> > >> > >> > -- >> > Hemant Purohit >> > Researcher, Ohio Center of Excellence in Knowledge-enabled >> Computing (Kno.e.sis) - FB LinkedIn Twitter G+ >> > _http://knoesis.wright.edu/researchers/hemant_ >> >> >> Dr. Tomi Kauppinen (PhD) >> Department of Media Technology >> School of Science, Aalto University_ >> __http://kauppinen.net/tomi__ >> __http://linkedscience.org/__ >> __http://twitter.com/LinkedScience_ >> >> >> >> >> -- >> Hemant Purohit >> Researcher, Ohio Center of Excellence in Knowledge-enabled >> Computing (Kno.e.sis) - _FB_ >> <https://www.facebook.com/Kno.e.sis>_LinkedIn_ >> <http://www.linkedin.com/company/kno-e-sis-center>_Twitter_ >> <https://www.twitter.com/knoesis>_G+_ >> <https://plus.google.com/114218038420056154466>_ >> __http://knoesis.wright.edu/researchers/hemant_ >> >>
Received on Monday, 13 January 2014 08:17:01 UTC