[Editorial suggestion] A one-word change to help readers: "standard"

https://w3c.github.io/csvw/syntax/#locating-metadata

My other suggested editorial improvements have fallen on deaf ears, so 
there seems to be no point in continuing to suggest anything more than 
the tiniest of changes.  With that in mind, I do have one suggestion for 
an extremely simple *one-word* *change* that would still improve the 
readability of this spec and help the community.

Please add the word "standard" to the phrase "default locations", 
"default URI patterns" and the like in Section 5 and the TOC, so that 
those phrases read: "standard default locations", "standard default URI 
patterns", etc.  This will help readers *find* the section that they 
need when they wish to look up the standard URI metadata filename 
patterns that they plan to use.

I recognize that for political or other reasons some members of the 
working group may wish to characterize these metadata filename patterns 
merely as algorithmic *defaults*, but I implore you as editors to think 
of this from the *user's* perspective.  The vast majority of users 
*will* *not* *care* about the "site-wide location configuration" 
feature.  They will think of these filename patterns as *standard* 
metadata filename patterns, *as* *indeed* *they* *will* *be* (though 
optional, because site administrators may override them):

  - they will be de jure standards, because they are standardized in 
this W3C Recommendation; and

  - they will also be de facto standards, because as we all know the 
vast majority of CSV metadata publishers will use those metadata 
filename patterns.

This is a *very* simple change to make.  Regardless of how pissed off 
you may be at me personally, *please* consider the best interest of the 
community as a whole and make this very simple change to help readers.

Thanks,
David Booth

Received on Wednesday, 18 November 2015 16:22:59 UTC