Thank you, Azucena, for your efforts in reconciling the viewpoints.
I will look for broader IETF input before commenting further, but
will note already that:
> PSO-PC has no strong objections to restrict the membership of the
> proposed ALSO to "those individuals holding a domain name".
is not consistent with:
> While the ALSC report concludes that this is a problem for e-mail
> based voter registration, it is our opinion that existing technical
> systems are not sufficient for precluding the same behaviour in
> individual domain registration based systems.
>
> If ICANN at large voting "membership" is important, tying it to
> second- or third-level domain name registrations could lead to
> the creation of more registrations that are not tied to functioning
> domains. It would then also tend to further flatten the tree. Neither
> of these is desirable.
Leslie.
azucena.hernandez@POP3.TELEFONICA.ES wrote:
>
> Dear Vlad, dear PSO-PC colleagues,
>
> Thanks a lot for your work on merging the 2 available contributions (ETSI
> and IETF) to the ALSC report.
>
> Since our last teleconference, ETSI Board members have made further comments
> to the ETSI contribution on the light of making it more acceptable to other
> PSO PC members. I detected some problems for Leslie and Steve accepting the
> bullet points related to having 6 seats for each SO in the ICANN Board. ETSI
> proposes to delete them and just keep a general point : same number of seats
> per SO (3 like now or even more if needed). I enclose a revised version of
> the document submited by Vlad.
>
> I have also rephrased the introduction to make it clearer (as for a
> non-english native reader).
>
> Both Tapio and myself are happy with this enclosed revision but we are ready
> to keep negotiating to get a single PSO PC reply.
>
> Kind regards,
> Azucena
>
> At 11:10 5/10/01 +0200, you wrote:
> >Hello,
> >Dear Protocol Council Members,
> >As you have decided during last conference call to merge the comments of
> ETSI and IETF to the ALSC Draft Report on the At-Large membership, please
> find attached the draft merged version for your consideration and comments.
> >Best regards,
> >Vladimir
> > <<PSOCommentstoALSCDraftReport.doc>>
> >
> >Attachment Converted: C:\Eudora\Attach\PSOCommentstoALSCDraftReport.doc
> >
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Part 1.2 Type: Microsoft Word Document (application/msword)
> Encoding: BASE64
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
> *************************************************
> Azucena Hernandez
> Telefonica
> Desarrollo de Red
> c/ Emilio Vargas, 4. E-28043-MADRID
> Tel: +34 91 5846842
> Fax: +34 91 5846843
> GSM: +34 609 425506
> E-Mail: azucena.hernandez@telefonica.es
> ************************************************
--
-------------------------------------------------------------------
"The best laid plans
are written in pencil."
-- ThinkingCat
Leslie Daigle
leslie@thinkingcat.com
-------------------------------------------------------------------